Lion's Mane vs. Cordyceps: Which Mushroom is Right for Your Supplement Line?

Two of the most commercially successful medicinal mushrooms — Lion's Mane and Cordyceps — serve very different consumer needs. Understanding the science behind each helps you build a more targeted, differentiated product line.

When supplement brands approach us about entering the medicinal mushroom market, the most common question we hear is: 'Which mushroom should I start with?' The answer depends entirely on your target consumer, your brand positioning, and the product format you have in mind. Two species consistently dominate the conversation — Lion's Mane (Hericium erinaceus) and Cordyceps (Cordyceps militaris) — and for good reason. Both have robust clinical research behind them, strong consumer awareness, and broad applicability across product formats.

The Science: What Makes Each Mushroom Unique

Lion's Mane is the only mushroom known to stimulate Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) synthesis in the brain. Its primary bioactive compounds — hericenones (found in the fruiting body) and erinacines (found in the mycelium) — cross the blood-brain barrier and promote neurogenesis. Clinical studies have demonstrated measurable improvements in mild cognitive impairment, anxiety, and depression scores after 8–16 weeks of supplementation. This makes it the definitive choice for any brand targeting the cognitive health, nootropic, or mental wellness space.

Cordyceps, by contrast, operates primarily on energy metabolism. Its key compound, cordycepin (3'-deoxyadenosine), mimics adenosine and enhances ATP production at the cellular level. Multiple studies have shown improvements in VO2 max, reduced fatigue, and enhanced oxygen utilization in both athletes and older adults. The sports nutrition and active lifestyle markets have embraced Cordyceps as a natural, non-stimulant performance enhancer — a significant differentiator from caffeine-based products.

Market Positioning: Where Each Mushroom Wins

Lion's Mane has found its most powerful market position in the 'mushroom coffee' trend. Blended with coffee or cacao, it masks its mild flavor while delivering a cognitive edge that resonates with productivity-focused consumers. It also performs exceptionally well in the 40+ demographic concerned about cognitive decline, and in the mental wellness space alongside adaptogens like Ashwagandha and L-Theanine. If your brand plays in any of these spaces, Lion's Mane is almost certainly your anchor ingredient.

Cordyceps dominates in sports nutrition and active lifestyle brands. Its non-stimulant mechanism makes it ideal for brands that want to differentiate from pre-workouts loaded with caffeine and synthetic compounds. It pairs exceptionally well with Rhodiola Rosea, Beetroot Extract, and B-vitamins in energy and endurance formulas. The 30ml–60ml shot format is particularly effective for Cordyceps, as the concentrated dose and on-the-go format align perfectly with the active consumer's lifestyle.

The Case for Combining Both

An increasingly popular strategy among our white label partners is to combine Lion's Mane and Cordyceps in a single 'Focus + Energy' formula. This synergistic approach addresses two of the most common consumer pain points simultaneously — mental clarity and physical vitality — while allowing a single SKU to compete across multiple market segments. Our standardized dual-extract blend of 500mg Lion's Mane (>30% beta-glucans) and 500mg Cordyceps (>0.3% cordycepin) is one of our most requested white label formulations.

"The most successful mushroom supplement brands we work with don't just sell a mushroom — they sell a specific outcome. 'Focus' sells better than 'Lion's Mane.' 'Energy without the crash' sells better than 'Cordyceps.' The mushroom is the proof point; the outcome is the promise."

Extraction Quality: The Factor That Determines Everything

Regardless of which mushroom you choose, the quality of the extract is the single most important factor in product efficacy — and therefore in customer retention and brand reputation. Both Lion's Mane and Cordyceps require dual extraction (hot water + ethanol) to capture the full spectrum of bioactive compounds. Water extraction alone captures polysaccharides and beta-glucans but misses the fat-soluble hericenones and erinacines in Lion's Mane, and the cordycepin in Cordyceps. At FUNGY, all our extracts are dual-extracted and standardized to verified bioactive content, with 3rd party lab testing on every batch.

The other critical quality marker is fruiting body vs. mycelium. Mycelium-on-grain products — common in the US market — contain significant amounts of starch from the growth substrate, diluting the actual mushroom content. Our extracts use 100% fruiting body material, ensuring that the standardized percentages on the certificate of analysis reflect actual mushroom bioactives, not grain starch.

Getting Started with Your Mushroom Line

If you're entering the medicinal mushroom market for the first time, we recommend starting with one of our white label formulations to validate your market and build consumer trust before investing in a fully custom private label formula. Our pilot run program allows you to launch with as few as 500 units in as little as 4–6 weeks, giving you real market data before committing to a larger production run. Contact our B2B team at [email protected] to request samples of both our Lion's Mane and Cordyceps extracts.

Related Articles